Pizza Payaa Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Pizza Payaa, a culinary gem nestled in Normal, Illinois, that stands out in the crowded pizza landscape. Their menu is a delightful exploration of flavors with standout offerings like the Brass Pig Reuben, featuring house-smoked pastrami and Detroit-style cheesy edges, and the unique Grilled Cheese Payaa, boasting an American cheese-stuffed crust and a delectable vodka sauce for dipping.

But it doesn’t stop there. The Calabrian Shrimp lightly smothered in creamy garlic sauce and the 8 or 16-piece Double Fried Chicken Wings reveal the kitchen’s knack for crafting crave-worthy appetizers. With an emphasis on quality ingredients and creative flair, options like the Honey Badger pizza, drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey, showcase various textures and tastes that are simply irresistible.

Whether you're dining in or enjoying takeout, Pizza Payaa promises a memorable experience filled with joyful flavors and welcoming service.

Features Starters Most Popular Red White Gourmet Sides Dessert Focaccia Sandwiches

Features

Brass Pig Reuben

Brass Pig Smoked Pastrami, House Russian Dressing, House Fermented Sauerkraut, Swiss, Detroit Cheesy Edges
$26.45

Grilled Cheese Payaa

American Cheese Stuffed Crust topped with Butter, Garlic and Mozzarella. Served with house made Vodka Sauce topped with Grana and Basil for dipping.**Can be made GF with 10/15 minutes extra prep time**
$24.15

Calabrian Shrimp

Creamy White Garlic Sauce, Calabrian Marinated Shrimp, Scallions, Lemon
$27.60

Spicy Muffuletta

Provolone, Capicola, Mortadella, Genoa Salami, Spicy Tapenade
$26.45

House Feta, Walnut, Cranberry Salad

Seasonal Greens, Candied Walnuts, Pickled Red Onions, Dried Cranberries, Feta, House Red Wine Vinaigrette**Contains Nuts**
$14.95

Truffalo Chicken Salad

Seasonal Greens, Bacon, Tomato, Pickled Red Onion, Oven Roasted Calabrian Chicken, Gorgonzola Crumbles, Spicy Truffle Ranch
$18.40

Carmella Soprano Salad

Crisp Iceberg, Roasted Red Peppers, Banana Peppers, Red Onion, Genoa Salami, Mortadella, Capicola, House Italian Vinaigrette, Provolone
$17.25

Wedge Salad

Iceberg, Bacon, Tomatoes, Pickled Red Onion, Gorgonzola Ranch, Freshly Cracked Black Pepper
$16.10

Cheesy Garlic Bread

Three Cheeses, Fresh Garlic Olive Oil, Comes with House Red, House Ranch or Hot Honey
$14.95

Cheesy Bacon Bread

Cheese and Bacon
$14.95

Double Fried Chicken Wings (8)

8 of our double fried crispy chicken wings.Gluten Free (Korean Sauce contains soy sauce and is NOT GF)
$14.95

Double Fried Chicken Wings (16)

16 of our double fried crispy chicken wings.Gluten Free(Korean Sauce contains soy sauce and is NOT GF)
$28.75

Cauliflower Wings

Fried Cauliflower tossed in your choice of our house made wing sauces.*only Sweet & Spicy Korean sauce is Vegan*Korean sauce is NOT GF but Cauliflower is
$14.95

Payaa Pieces

Dough Bites served with your choice of one of our house made dipping sauces**Cannot be made GF**
$9.20

Starters

Most Popular

Honey Badger

Ezzo Pepperoni, Fennel Sausage, Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle, Fresh Basil
$25.30

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Calabrian Marinated Chicken, Bacon, House Ranch
$24.15

4 Cheese with Basil

Detroit-Inspired: Extra Cheesy Caramelized Edges, Fresh Mozz, Red Sauce, Fresh Basil
$21.85

The Fig and the Pig

Mozzarella, Gorgonzola, Asiago, Fig Jam, Crispy Prosciutto, Balsamic Glaze
$25.30

Pepperoni Burrata Be Kidding Me!

Ezzo Pepperoni topped with a whole Burrata, drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey and Fresh Basil
$28.75

Sausage Fun Guy

Creamy White Garlic Sauce, Fennel Sausage, Roasted Mushrooms, Fresh Scallions
$24.15

Bad Boy

Detroit-Inspired: Extra Cheesy Caramelized Edges, Extra Pep, Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle
$25.30

Tammy Supreme

Everything! Pepperoni, Sausage, Roasted Mushrooms, Red Onions, Green Peppers, Black Olives
$27.60

Burrata Vodka Pesto

Mozzarella, Garlic Olive Oil, Vodka Sauce, Grana, Burrata, Fresh Basil, Pesto
$25.30

BYO Payaa

Build Your Own Payaa
$18.40

Three Cheese with Basil

House Cheese Blend, House Red Sauce, Freshly Grated Grana Padano, Fresh Basil
$18.40

Cheese Burrata Be Kidding Me!

Three Cheese topped with a whole Burrata, Mike's Hot Honey drizzle and Fresh Basil
$25.30

Hot Boy

Ezzo Pepperoni, House Pickled Jalapenos, Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle
$23.00

Pepperoni

Thick Cut Ezzo Pepperoni - The Best!
$21.85

Pepperoni and Sausage

Ezzo Pepperoni, Fennel Sausage
$25.30

Red Sausage

Fennel Sausage, Red Sauce
$21.85

Sweet Heat

Pepperoni, Banana Peppers, Hot Honey Drizzle, Fresh Basil
$23.00

Veggie Supreme

Roasted Mushrooms, Red Onions, Green Peppers, Black Olives, Fresh Basil
$23.00

Vegan Pepperoni Payaa

Vegan Mozzarella, Vegan Pepperoni, Garlic Olive Oil, Fresh Basil**contains cashews**
$24.15

Red

White

Fun Guy

White Garlic Sauce, Double Roasted Cremini and Button Mushrooms, Grana Padano, Chives
$21.85

White Garlic Sausage

Creamy White Garlic Sauce, Fennel Sausage, Freshly Grated Grana
$21.85

Vodka Pep

Extra Pepperoni, Garlic Olive Oil, House Vodka Sauce, Fresh Basil
$24.15

Buffalo Chicken

Brown Butter Buffalo Chicken, Ranch, Scallions
$23.00

Chipotle BBQ Chicken

House Chipotle BBQ, Chicken, Red Onion, House Pickled Jalapeños, Smoked Mozzarella
$23.00

Gourmet

Sides

Side of Burrata

Fresh Mozzarella wrapped around Fresh Cream
$5.75

I Love You S'More Than Pizza

Nutella, Toasted Marshmallows, Graham Cracker
$11.50

Dessert

Focaccia Sandwiches

Vodka Chicken Parm

Hand Breaded Italian Chicken, Vodka Sauce, Pesto, Burrata on House Baked FocacciaServed with Potato ChipsOnly available 11am to 2pm Monday thru Friday
$18.40

The Tony Soprano

House Foccacia, Thinly sliced Mortadella, Salami, Capicola and Provolone, Calabrian Chili Aioli, Iceberg, Red Onion, Roasted Red Peppers, Banana Peppers, Italian Vinaigrette Served with Potato Chips
$17.25